Vendor consolidation with a top 10 pharma company
Case study
A Top 10 pharmaceutical client was seeking an innovative solution to consolidate site management services under a single functional service provider (FSP). With approximately 70% of their R&D pipeline managed by full-service CROs and 30% insourced with mix of CROs, agencies, and independent contractors, the disparate delivery model limited the client’s control and ownership of key assets throughout the R&D life cycle. The client selected ICON as a sole source FSP partner to implement a workforce transformation operating model that not only provided the client with strategic control and addressed these risks and inefficiencies, but that also retained as many experienced resources as possible.
The challenge
The new model had to give the client the strategic control required to inform their decision-making process while also addressing several risks and inefficiencies, including:
- Lack of standardisation due to decentralised resourcing functions and variability in local delivery models and procedures
- Locally managed resourcing strategy resulted in role description inconsistencies, resource forecasting challenges, and varying ramp up/down abilities to meet pipeline demands
- High administrative burden placed on the client’s operational and business management staff
- Budget and invoicing inconsistencies and inefficiencies
- High, variable costs with US-based contractors due to billing by the hour, hours billed exceeding the hours projected for tasks, and unpredictable contractor absences
- Co-employment risks and compliance issues
The solution
The ICON and client leadership team implemented a workforce transformation model in order to preserve business continuity. This was guided by the partnership’s Global Rules of Engagement to serve as a comprehensive guide for operational integration as well as a central location for the partnership’s overarching principles, governance structure, communications pathways and metrics.
Pre-implementation planning:
Upon award, ICON and the client developed a governance structure facilitating transparency, risk management, and issue resolution at the lowest level to minimise impact.
Due to the complex scope, ICON and client created a responsibility matrix for each activity supported by a robust Communication Plan that detailed role-level reporting requirements, issue resolution, and escalation pathways. Per our risk and issue management and mitigation methodology, we implemented a Risk Register to track risk/issue probability, impact, and response strategies and actions as well as growth opportunities at the global, regional, and country level. ICON developed a robust resourcing and retention strategy including, the creation of a client-dedicated Talent Acquisition team.
Partnership evolution:
The overall aim was to simplify management of personnel by harmonising business processes in a collaborative partnership and to oversee the partnership using a strong, multi-tiered (global/ regional/local) governance model to ensure effective communications and operations. During this process, ICON and our sponsor encountered several challenges and learning opportunities, which included:
- Creation of consistent global operating model with knowledge of and respect for local labor restrictions to mitigate co-employment risk.
- Management of change averse culture by providing regular education on program intricacies via worldwide regional implementation meetings.
- Development of a risk management methodology with implementation of a risk register and a focus on proactivity, risk prevention, and reduction of impact.
With 80% of workforce as contractors, there was a significant risk of loss of business continuity due to non-conversion. To reduce risk, ICON implemented the following:
- Establishment of exception process to manage unforeseen salary expectations.
- Rapid planned replacement process with adequate handover period to minimise business disruption.
- Extension of vendor contracts to assure smooth transition.
- Collaboration between ICON and sponsor to ensure continual status updates and alignment on areas of focus.
- Flexibility on start dates to accommodate vendor and individual preferences.
- Flexibility on working location to meet individual preferences.
The outcomes
Conversion process
-
98%
of the resources insourced within a year -
167
resources fully transitioned after 14 months -
98%
retention rate a year post-transition
Cost savings
-
13%
cost saving per resource -
€18m
indirect savings in Year 1 -
91%
reduction in administrative burden
Expansion
-
16
compounds receiving support across 3 therapeutic areas -
19
new roles and 6 functions added in Year 1 -
467%
exponential growth, reaching 780+ resources